Recommended Insurers


Protecting Your Investment with Local Experts


One of the most common questions I hear from buyers—especially those new to Florida—is: "Who should I trust for home insurance?" And it's no wonder. Florida's insurance market is unique, with considerations like wind coverage, flood zones, and replacement costs that don't exist in most other states.


The good news? You don't need to figure this out alone. I've cultivated relationships with trusted local insurance professionals who understand our specific coastal market. These aren't faceless 1-800 numbers—they're neighbors who answer their phones, know the difference between a 32963 zip code and a 32905, and will fight for you when you need them most.


Below are my recommendations, organized by county and specialty.

  • Brevard County Recommendations

    Wren Insurance Agency – Palm Bay


    Established 1979 | Locally Owned and Operated


    For more than four decades, people have confidently turned to Wren Insurance Agency for their insurance needs. Founded by Skip Wren in 1979, the agency has grown to become one of the largest insurance agencies in Brevard County. Today, it's owned by Kirk and Meghan (Wren) Ball, who continue the family tradition of providing cost-effective insurance solutions and exceptional client service .


    Why I recommend them:


    - Deep roots in Brevard County since 1979

    - One of the largest agencies in the county, offering stability and carrier options

    - Serves thousands of individuals, families, and businesses throughout Brevard County and across Florida

    - Family-owned with a reputation for personalized service


    Location: Palm Bay Rd, Palm Bay


    Hours: Monday-Friday 9am-5pm

  • Blue Sky Insurance Agency – Cocoa Village

    Women-Owned | Independent Agency


    Located in historic Cocoa Village, Blue Sky Insurance Agency is a full-service Property & Casualty agency specializing in Homeowner's, Business Owner's, and Liability insurance. As an independent agency, they represent a select group of financially sound, respected insurance companies, meaning they can place your policy with the company offering the best coverage and price for your specific needs .


    Why I recommend them:


    - Independently owned and operated, with a focus on personalized service

    - Access to multiple carriers ensures competitive pricing

    - Friendly, professional staff who assist from first purchase through claims resolution

    - Women-owned business with strong community ties


    Owner: Robyn Killary-Greene


    Location: 25 Stone Street, Cocoa Village, FL 32922


    Phone: 321-636-8878

  • Space Coast Home Insurance Solutions – Palm Bay

    Space Coast Home Insurance Solutions – Palm Bay


    Local Specialists in Brevard County Home Insurance


    True to their name, this agency focuses specifically on home insurance solutions for Brevard County residents. They serve numerous communities including Indialantic, June Park, Malabar, Melbourne, Melbourne Beach, Melbourne Village, Palm Bay, and West Melbourne. Whether you need help dealing with damage to your residence, theft of possessions, or personal liability, their team works through every situation with you .


    Why I recommend them:


    - Hyper-focused on Brevard County home insurance

    - Serve a wide range of local communities

    - Emphasize personal service and walking clients through every situation


    Location: 1945 Palm Bay Rd NE, Palm Bay, FL 32905


    Phone: (808) 825-6827

  • GEICO Local Office – Vero Beach

    Opened 2022 | Local Agents with National Backing


    In 2022, GEICO opened a local office in Vero Beach to serve customers in Vero Beach, Sebastian, Fort Pierce, Indian River, St. Lucie, and Okeechobee counties. Led by Maggie Deng, a University of Florida graduate with insurance experience dating back to 2009, this office offers the convenience of local agents backed by one of the nation's largest insurers .


    What they offer:


    - Auto, home, renters, condo, and flood insurance

    - Coverage for boats, RVs, motorcycles, and personal watercraft

    - Multi-policy discounts

    - Alumni discounts for University of Florida, UCF, USF, and Palm Beach State College graduates


    Location: 921 15th Place, Vero Beach


    Hours: Monday-Friday 8:30am-5:30pm, Saturday 10am-2pm


    Phone: (772) 400-6680

  • What National Companies Offer Competitive Rates

    While I strongly recommend starting with local independent agents who can shop multiple carriers for you, the search results also confirm that several national insurers are competitive in our market. According to recent data, homeowners in Indian River County can expect to pay between $800 and $3,000 annually for standard coverage, with rates varying significantly by neighborhood .


    National carriers with competitive rates in our area include:


    - State Farm

    - Allstate

    - Farmers

    - Travelers

    - Nationwide

    - USAA (for military-affiliated families)

    - Liberty Mutual

    - Amica

    - Chubb (for high-value homes) 

1. Do you understand the specific risks of my property's location? (Flood zone? Wind zone? Proximity to coast?)

2. What carriers do you represent, and how do you determine which one is best for my situation?

3. What discounts are available? (New roof? Security system? Bundling? Loyalty?)

4. How do you handle claims? Will you advocate for me?

5. Do I need flood insurance? Even if not required by your lender, it's worth understanding your risk.

6. What is the replacement cost of my home, and how did you calculate it?

7. What's not covered in a standard policy that I should consider adding?

Questions to Ask Any Insurance Agent

A Note from Andonia


Insurance is one of those things you hope you never need—until you desperately do. When that day comes, you want someone who answers the phone, knows your name, and understands exactly what you're going through.


The agents listed above are people I trust with my own clients. They've proven themselves over years of working together. Some have even saved my clients thousands of dollars by catching errors or fighting for better classifications.


If you're in the process of buying a home, I'm happy to make an introduction to any of these providers. Just let me know which part of our region you're focused on, and I'll connect you with the right person.

Contact Us